High school sweethearts Jaime Goldstein and Henrik Sukonnik first started dating during their junior year. After five years together, Henrik popped the question.
To celebrate Jaime's college graduation, Henrik took her to New York City to see American Idiot on Broadway, followed by a fancy dinner at Daniel. At the restaurant, Henrik pretended to drop something on the floor — and then he got on one knee and pulled out a ring. "It was completely unexpected and shocking, but one of the best nights of my life," recalled Jaime. "After, he told me he hadn't been able to enjoy the show because he was so worried; the ring was loose in the side pocket of his coat, and I had been using his coat on my lap to keep warm!"
Photo Credit: Casey Fatchett Photography
Featured: Mindy Weiss on How to Save Money on
Your Wedding Without Sacrificing Style.
Get more planning advice here.