A Pirate's Life: Cat & Phil in Calistoga, CA
Almost two years after meeting through an online dating site, Phil proposed to Cat during a romantic weekend away at Scottsdale Omni Resort & Spa. "He whisked me away for a surprise weekend for his birthday weekend, so I wouldn't be suspicious," Cat recalled. While relaxing by one of the resort's outdoor fireplaces, Phil pulled out a box with a Lord of the Rings ring, a handmade scroll with the movie's "Ring Verse," and asked Cat to marry him. "Shocked, it took a few seconds before I said yes!"
Browse More Real Weddings
See More Photos